However, I am not familiar enough with what the law says is plagiarism. It occurs within the contour of the line, as opposed to how Ice Box and aLttP use the three-note grouping: isolated, as a theme.Īs a composer, it is my professional opinion that Ice Box and the aLttP dungeon theme are far too similar for them to be completely unrelated. In Cloudburst, it is more subtle, and occurs within an ascending arpeggio, lining out a minor ninth chord (which contains these scale degrees: 1, m3, P5, m7, M9( same as M2)) Here's somewhat of a format: 1, _, _, M2, m3, m7, _, _. It occurs in Eric Whitacre's "Cloudburst", published in 1995 (and probably in plenty of other places as well). I can think of another instance of the M2 m3 m7 ascending combination. Is this plagiarism? Let me say a little more before I answer that. There is an undeniable similarity between the melodic motion of Ice Box and aLttP's dungeon. However, Ice Box still has the same 3-note theme. Ice Box also changes keys, but in a more conventional way: iv to i. In the third phrase, aLttP moves yet another half-step lower, keeping the same notes. Notice, however, that the note it changes is a half-step lower, which is why it sounds similar to the aLttP second phrase. aLttP moves to another key, a half-step lower, while Ice Box stays in iv, but changes the last note. We can see the obvious similarity between the first two phrases. The scale degrees the aLttP dungeon uses are:
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |